censure allnodes for insecure VaaS practices
passed
Expected result
—
Turnout / Quorum
48.32% / 33.40%
75.77%
39 124 034 akt
Yes
5.05%
2 606 804 akt
No
0.14%
72 260 akt
Veto
19.04%
9 833 936 akt
Abstain
Details
Proposer
-
Total deposit
1 069 akt
Submit time
2023.02.06 at 14:02:58
Deposit end time
2023.02.20 at 14:02:58
Description
Description
Allnodes.com is a provider of VaaS (validator as a service). Here is a document containing proof of their insecure activities:
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1AIOOrHiNAFQKwzaeDNyJJJx8SwXNlaSUcZbasnezXS4/edit?usp=sharing
To discuss this proposal on twitter:
https://twitter.com/gadikian/status/1622586151235391488
The twitter thread above also contains conclusive proof that allnodes.com is currently offering to create operator wallets for their users, in contravention of "not your keys, not your coins."
Allnodes VaaS harms the security of Akash, so we are seeking to censure (formally criticize) them in this governance proposal.
By voting yes, you:
- agree that allnodes is harmful to the akash network
- seek to formally criticize them for behaving in an insecure manner.
- recommend redelegation away from allnodes and their customers, since they are not distinct from each other due to poor key management practices
Votes
Voter
Answer